MCF Market Watch


Welcome!


In the interest of keeping our clientele educated and well-informed in a trying economy, MCF issues bi-weekly market assessments.

Go to our web site to subscribe to this and other news and tools, including the MCF Rate Sheet and Mortgage Solutions - Real Quotes On Real Deals (TM).

Follow us online! 


Monday, July 6, 2009

Coming Home To Roost

Doug Marshall
Market Assessment
Published July 6, 2009

The numbers are alarming… probably because they’re simply so huge. And for some reason, the conversation about this doesn’t seem to be happening.

While most attention in commercial real estate today is focused on the dramatic deterioration in term loan performance (i.e. defaulting loans), an even more troublesome issue is the extent to which loans originated during the 2005-2007 period will encounter significant problems, refinancing at maturity.

A report dated April 22nd, from the prestigious Deutsche Bank Securities research group, focused on this refinancing issue. Shown below is a chart showing the annual maturities of loans by lender classification.
The conclusions drawn by Deutsch Bank Research are manifold, and are a great cause for unease:

· Commercial real estate prices have already plummeted 25-30% from their peak in 2007 due to the enormous changes in available financing terms (lower LTVs, higher interest rates, etc).

Further declines may be expected based purely on the degrading economy (which is resulting in higher vacancy and lower rental rates), pushing values down another 15-25%.

· The decline in commercial real estate values in the 2005-2007 period will make it very difficult for many properties to refinance when their loans come due.

They predict that two thirds of the loans maturing between 2009 and 2018 ($410 billion) are unlikely to qualify for refinancing at maturity without significant equity infusions from borrowers.

· This group estimates that the equity deficiency that would have to be made up by borrowers themselves tops $100 billion.

Solutions that have been floated to solve this problem seem, at best, naïve. One idea that has been presented is that banks and other lending institutions facing this refinancing wave will simply agree to extend the maturity dates.

This incorrectly assumes that either: 1) the lender, by shortening the amortization of the loan, will sufficiently help accelerate the pay down of the loan; or that 2) extending the loan term provides the property time to achieve additional growth in value so the loan can qualify for refinancing.

With respect to the first possibility, the report concludes that the value deficiency for many loans is far too large to be tackled by simply accelerating the amortization over a reasonable time period. And with respect to value growth, the likelihood of significant property price appreciation is remote.

It’s a gloomy forecast. We strongly encourage borrowers to determine whether any of their loans are currently “upside down.”

This can be determined simply by taking current interest rates, cap rates, and underwriting terms to calculate whether their new loan would qualify for refinancing at more or less than the existing loan amount.

If the new loan is less than the existing loan you’ve got a problem; and now is the time to start working on a solution, not when the loan is due.

If you or a client of yours would like help estimating a new loan for their property under today’s lending criteria we are ready to assist you. Please do not hesitate to contact us for a no-obligation loan estimate today.

Source:
Potential Refinancing Crisis in Commercial Real Estate, April 22, 2009, by Deutche Bank Securities, Inc.

Tuesday, June 16, 2009

The Fourth Horseman of the Apocalypse - When?

Doug Marshall
Market Assessment
Published June 16, 2009

Many have written on the reasons and rationale for the current market and economy downturn, including us. But for many struggling in this debt-toxic atmosphere, especially in the real estate industry, the more pressing question remains: what’s still to come?

Prognosticators abound but we are intrigued by the long-maintained predictions of Dennis Torres, a California broker and head of Pepperdine University’s Real Estate Operations department.

Mr. Torres spoke out three years ago about the impending doom that is the current housing market crisis. In an article for Realtor Magazine, he has put into context the “four horsemen of the real estate market apocalypse” that that we are currently or will be experiencing.

The first three have come to pass. They have wreaked havoc on the U.S. economy and the shock waves continue: 1) the collapse of the sub-prime loan market followed by losses in the prime mortgage market; 2) high and increasing unemployment; and 3) the resulting escalation of the burden of consumer debt, especially credit card debt, on the economy.

But Mr. Torres’ “fourth horseman” remains on the horizon and could have a more long-lasting effect on the economy, and the real estate industry, than many believe or are talking about. And that ghost of ill wind is the one of rampant inflation.

The reasons are simple. Where are our bailouts to the banks, the auto industry, etc., coming from? How is our government paying for the wars? They’re printing money, of course, and you can’t do that without it losing some of its intrinsic value.

In the real estate world, what does this mean? Mr. Torres believes inflation will take hold within the next two years. Before that time home values will decline then stagnate until 2015 before climbing due to inflation.

The difficulty for consumers, in keeping their homes and paying their bills with paychecks that don’t match rising inflation, is going to have good and bad effects on the markets.

High prices for durable goods will be matched, says Mr. Torres, with increasing values in homes as the prices go higher.

And Mr. Torres doesn’t fear another housing market collapse, as those prices will be “based on the intrinsic value of the then-current dollar.”

So how will inflation affect commercial real estate? Rents and expenses will likely keep pace with inflation. So will interest rates.

Who will be the winners if inflation is rampant? Those lessees who negotiate favorable lease rates today and lock in their rates for as long as possible will be one group of winners.

And those borrowers who finance a property this year with long-term fixed rates will look back years from now and crow about how farsighted they were to realize the importance of locking in a rate when rates were comparatively low.

Mr. Torres calls the potential for high inflation “unsettling.” But in reality there will be winners and losers in this type of real estate market.

To be one of the winners will take a positive attitude, seeing the opportunities before us, and having the foresight to adapt real estate skills to take advantage of the market.

Source:

“Inflation on the Horizon?” by Dennis Torres, Realtor magazine, June 2009

Wednesday, June 3, 2009

The Last To Go – And The Next One Coming

Doug Marshall
Market Assessment
Published June 3, 2009



The housing crisis – the frozen credit tundra – the bipolar stock market… We’ve heard these bad tidings for over a year now, and more.

What is not being talked up yet (because we’re only on the cusp of it), is the rise in commercial real estate foreclosures and the potential impact that future defaults on commercial loans might have on an already wobbly economy.

Commercial real estate has been one of the last sectors to feel the pinch, being relatively stable and containing a lower default rate… underpinned by easy credit already obtained.

This interactive map (rollover your county) is a great resource for seeing how the economy is currently doing; it also gives rise to questions as to how various areas in the country might be affected by this trend.

The fallout due to the bad economy is already being felt. Linens ‘N’ Things, Circuit City, and many more… these large corporations are in serious trouble – leaving storefronts behind, vacant as they close down, declaring bankruptcy, or going out of business altogether.

“Delinquency rates and defaults on office and retail buildings and hotels have more than doubled in just six months.

For apartments and industrial buildings, rates have increased more than 80 percent, according to Reis, Inc,” says the Associated Press.

The impact on the economy of the coming wave of bankruptcies is hard to gauge.

But some pundits heralding “slight rebounds” in current market trends should take an honest look at this long-range financial impact on commercial real estate.

It’s not over yet.


Source:
Alex Veiga, StarTribune.com
May 11, 2009

Thursday, May 28, 2009

No More Pie In My Sky

Doug Marshall
Market Assessment
Published May 27, 2009


What do borrowers have to do get the financing that they require to survive the credit crisis? Ryan Krauch, writing for CIRE Magazine, is emphatic (and very right) on this point – borrowers are going to be forced to adjust their realities.

The good ol’ days are just that – OLD. They are gone; they’re over and done with and they’re not coming back… at least not in the short term. CMBS loans are a thing of the past, as are loan applications that contain questionable data on the borrower.

So a new manual has to be written for those poor souls in this predicament. And they’re not going to like it.

Borrowers’ Tips For Survival:

· Fundamentals Matter – Underwriting a loan is now going to require proof of real, sustainable business plans and exit strategies. Lenders will be tight with they’re requirements and disciplined with their processes.

· Operating Track Records Count – Padded pro formas that assume more than can be proven are a thing of the past. Real, tangible numbers that prove the value of the property will be required.

· Borrowers Must Be Well-Capitalized – Nope, sorry, investors will need to put a lot more capital into a deal in order to get financing. “Significant equity” will be required of borrowers in order to obtain financing.

· Capital Costs More – There are borrowers out there who, because of the free-and-easy way in which they have acquired capital in the past, get downright belligerent when told that their new money is going to cost them more. It’s true, though; spreads will be higher, lenders will be hedging against risk, and pricing continues to climb.

The deals are still there to do. The money is around, though more difficult to find. And the work required to get it, as well as the burden now placed back on borrowers, to achieve it is substantial.

However, if this market is going to right itself again and become what it should – a disciplined and reasonable industry – the pain is going to have to precede the gain. Sorry…


Source:
Ryan Krauch, “Back To Basics”, CIRE Magazine's Financing Focus, May 15, 2009

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Economic Quagmire Requires A Return To Basic Principles

Doug Marshall
Market Assessment
Published May 14, 2009



Back in January I wrote an article titled How To Survive the Economic Downturn. The Portland Business Journal recently printed it in a shorter version, shown below.
_____________________________________________

The downward spiraling of the economy. No one knows where this is heading. What’s worse: there is very little you can do to minimize the carnage. But here are some time-proven principles which, if applied, can help us out of this quagmire.

GO BACK TO THE BASICS
For those in any kind of sales profession, marketing is critical. Success depends almost solely on how many marketing contacts one can make in a week.

So now that the phone has stopped ringing, go back to square one.

STAY FOCUSED
What one thing will best help you survive? Identify it, and forget all the distractions. So-called “important” issues often sidetrack a company’s focus.

WHAT SETS YOU APART?
Consider a brutally honest self-assessment. What core competency distinguishes you from your competition? What do you do that is no different than anyone else?

If you can’t differentiate your product or service from your competition, you’re in deep trouble. You end up being just one of many possible choices for your clients. Focus on things that make you unique.

BE 100% COMMITTED TO YOUR CAREER
I had a friend, years ago, who worked at a start-up. I remember him saying that, if it didn’t work out, he had another lucrative opportunity with a newly established dot-com company. The wiggle room gave him room to fail.

It’s difficult to succeed in any profession if you’re not 100 percent committed to it.

Within a year, my friend was out of the commercial mortgage business and the lucrative job offer with the dot-com never materialized.

IF NECESSARY REDEFINE YOURSELF
Sometimes after you go through the self assessment process, you realize you’re not the problem. The market is.

If that is true, find a new niche within your profession. For example, if you work in the residential real estate market, maybe you can move some business into the reverse mortgage industry, currently a lucrative market.

With every change in the economy there are winners and losers. Find those clients who are in the most financial pain resulting from the poor economy. They are the ones in need of assistance.
STAY POSITIVE
A positive attitude is the most important thing to focus on during difficult times. Here are some suggestions:

  • Avoid negative people. We all know who they are. Avoid them at all costs.
  • Don’t go it alone. Find someone, or maybe more than one person, with whom you can share your deepest fears. Don’t be a Lone Ranger.

DEEP-SIX WHAT DOESN’T WORK
Albert Einstein once said, “The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again, expecting different results.” Have you been doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results?

A bad economy can sometimes be a blessing in disguise. It can force you to make decisions that you’ve known in the back of your mind had to be made.

DON’T GIVE UP
In his book, Good To Great, Jim Collins refers to the Stockdale Paradox, named after Vice Admiral James Stockdale. While in a Vietnamese prison, Stockdale encouraged his men to retain their faith that they would prevail. The same is true for us:

  • Retain absolute faith that you can and will prevail in the end, regardless of the difficulties you face.
  • At the same time, confront the most brutal facts of your current reality, whatever they might be.
When all else fails, that attitude can carry one through many, many difficult times. Don’t give up, no matter what.


Source:
As printed in The Portland Business Journal, May 1, 2009 For the full text of this article go to the Marshall Commercial Funding web site blog, at
www.marshallcf.com.