MCF Market Watch


Welcome!


In the interest of keeping our clientele educated and well-informed in a trying economy, MCF issues bi-weekly market assessments.

Go to our web site to subscribe to this and other news and tools, including the MCF Rate Sheet and Mortgage Solutions - Real Quotes On Real Deals (TM).

Follow us online! 


Showing posts with label U.S. National Debt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label U.S. National Debt. Show all posts

Friday, February 22, 2013

Sequestration – Will it be as devastating as predicted?

You’ve heard it from both sides of the aisle – Nancy Pelosi, John McCain, President Obama, Mitch McConnell – sequestration will be “devastating.”  “We’ve got to avoid it, we’ve got to stop it,” said John McCain.  He is being universally echoed with similar quotes by all of the Democrat leadership in Congress.  Let’s begin this discussion with the facts. 

What is sequestration?  Sequestration is a budget law that requires across the board spending cuts amounting to $1.2 trillion over 10 years or $109 billion per year.   

How much will be cut in 2013?  The last minute fiscal cliff deal in early January included cuts of $24 billion for 2013, so in the remaining seven months of this fiscal year the government must cut another $85 billion. 

How much is the federal government’s budget for the current fiscal year?  $3.8 trillion

Where would the cuts come from?  Equal amounts would come from the Defense Department and discretionary social spending.  The Defense Department makes up about one-quarter of the total federal budget; discretionary social spending comprises about half of the total budget, and non-discretionary social spending and the interest on the debt making up the balance. 

So who will be most affected by the cuts?  The cuts on a percentage basis would be deepest in defense spending because it represents a quarter of the budget but half of the cuts.

What programs won’t be cut?  Social security, Medicaid, the food stamp program and veteran’s benefits.  Active duty personnel would also be exempt.  Interestingly, Medicare is not exempt.

When does sequestration begin?  Officially it begins March 1st but in reality it will roll out over a period of several weeks.

So those are the facts.  Now let’s look at what the impact of these cuts in spending will have on our economy.  The Congressional Budget Office predicts that the sequestration cuts will reduce public- and private-sector employment by 750,000 jobs and will reduce our GDP by 0.5%.  In other words, our GDP, which is growing at about 2.0% right now, would slow to about 1.5%.  Depending on who you listen to the list of programs that will be affected is long and deep including:

  • the Federal Aviation Administration,
  • the National Parks,
  • the Pentagon, 
  • Health and Human Services, 
  • Humanitarian Aid,
  • Border Security,
  • Education,
  • Disaster Relief
  • Law Enforcement 
The list appears to be endless.  This is what those in power are saying, in a nutshell, “The world is coming to an end as we know it.”  They may not use these exact words but that is what they are trying to convey.  I respectfully disagree.  Yes there will be consequences to making these cuts.  There will be some pain but the world will go on and in the long run we’ll all be better for it.  

Sadly, there are very few politicians in Washington who are willing to make modest cuts in spending, and make no mistake about it, that is what $1.2 trillion is over 10 years.  A cut of $85 billion in fiscal 2013 represents 2.3% of the total $3.8 trillion federal budget.  Do you actually believe that a 2.3% cut in spending is going to be “devastating?”  Have you had to make cuts in personal spending that have been much greater than this over the past several years?  I certainly have.   

The sequestration cuts are not perfect, they’re a blunt instrument to cut spending, rather than a deliberate plan that sets priorities, trims entitlements, and cuts other spending.  It would be better to replace them with better cuts but the reality is that Washington does not have the will to make spending cuts.  There is no political block in Washington that represents the constituency of the overburdened taxpayer.  In contrast, there are thousands of lobbyists on Capitol Hill that visit our congressional representatives in order to make sure that they’re constituency, whatever that may be, is getting their fair share of the spending pie. 

Don’t buy into the hysteria.  The cuts will not be devastating.  If the sequestration cuts actually happen, six months from now you’ll hardly notice. 

Sources: Sequestration Q & A, Money Watch, by Jill Schlesinger, February 22, 2013; Sequestration: The Facts About the Policy, BeforeItsNews.com, February, 19, 2013; The GOP Divide Over Sequestration (and Everything Else), The Atlantic, by Molly Ball, February 15, 2013.

Saturday, January 26, 2013

John Mitchell and the Four Fairies

Last week’s blog post I referred to a presentation John Mitchell gave at the annual HFO Investor Roundtable event on January 8th.  I specifically honed in on his comments about interest rates.  If you missed it, I would encourage to find the link to last week’s article located in the lower right hand column of this email under Recent Blog Posts and read the article. 

But there was also another part of his January 8th presentation that I want to focus in on in today’s blog post.  Mr. Mitchell began this part of his presentation talking about his four year old granddaughter Stella who recently lost a tooth.  As Mr. Mitchell, heartily emphasized, “When your four years old losing a tooth is a big deal!”  And so it is because you get introduced to the Tooth Fairy who exchanges the tooth under the pillow for money.  When I was her age, I think the Tooth Fairy usually gave me a dime for my tooth.  I bet Stella received a whole lot more than a dime, at least I hope so. 

Mr. Mitchell then segued his discussion about the Tooth Fairy into the four fairies that many adults these days appear to believe in.  I thought his presentation was insightful, if not absolutely courageous, considering the likelihood of offending many of the people in his audience.  The four fairies are:

1.   The Free Medical Services Fairy – Think about it.  Medical services have never been and never will be free.  It takes real resources to pay for them.  Someone has to pay for them or they don’t exist. 

2.   The Entitlements Fairy – this fairy pays all the promises that our politicians have enacted through legislation down through the generations.  This fairy waves her magic wand and all entitlements are fully funded.

3.   The No New Taxes Fairy – this fairy may have died on December 31st of last year but those who believe in this fairy believe that we are going to fix our fiscal crisis with no new taxes.  If you look at the numbers (most people don’t look at the numbers because ignorance is preferred over making informed decisions) what you find is that the sum of all federal revenues – corporate, personal, social security, tariffs, etc. there is just enough revenue to pay for Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, interest on the debt and the federal retirement program.  The problem is there is another trillion dollars worth of spending that is left unfunded. 

4.   The Rich Will Pay Fairy – Again look at the numbers.  The top 1% of income earners pay 29% of all federal taxes; the top 20% pay 70% of all federal taxes.  Anyway you look at it the rich cannot fill the gigantic fiscal deficit that we have today.  I (Doug Marshall) have never understood how those who self righteously believe that the wealthy (I’m unfortunately not one of them) should “pay their fair share” think that it is perfectly okay that the bottom 47% of the population pays no federal income taxes.  Could someone explain that to me?  Whatever happened to the idea that all of us should pay our fair share of taxes proportional to our means?   

I want to end this article with two quotes which I believe are appropriate for our current fiscal situation:

“People only accept change when they are faced with necessity, and only recognize necessity when a crisis is upon them. “ Jean Monnet

“If something cannot go on forever, it will stop.” Herbert Stein

The fiscal path that the federal government is on is unsustainable.  Why not fix the problem while there is still time to act? 

Tuesday, January 1, 2013

My Crystal Ball Forecast for 2013

Forecasting reminds me of the quote attributed to one of our most famous philosophers of the 21st century, Yogi Berra.  He said, “It’s tough to make predictions, especially about the future.”  But it’s that time of year when we all want to know what the new year is going to bring.  Specifically those of us in commercial real estate want to know, “How is commercial real estate going to do in the Pacific Northwest in 2013?” 

Well you’ve come to the right place because I’m bullish about the immediate future of commercial real estate.  Interest rates should remain low throughout 2013.  Commercial real estate should continue its upward trend out of our plunge into the abyss caused by the Great Recession of 2008.  Four years ago we were in a free fall, similar to a skydiver who waits as long as possible before he pulls the ripcord that opens his parachute.  It looked bleak.  Let me correct myself.  It was bleak.  But in 2010 we bottomed out and 2011 showed a modest improvement.  Last year was even better and there is no reason to believe this trend won’t continue into 2013.  
However there are three caveats to this prediction.  As James Carville once said, “It’s the economy stupid.”  And sure enough how well we do in 2013 assumes that the economy continues to grow at the modest pace that it has grown for the past few years.  If not, then all bets are off.  There are three things that could derail our economy. 
1.  The Slow Down of the World Economy 
Even though 70% of our economy is derived from domestic spending, the United States is not immune to what happens in the rest of the world.   And what is happening in the rest of the world?  Europe is in recession and the economies of other countries are slowing down.   This means that there will be less demand for our exports, which means our economy will begin to feel the affect.  However, I don’t believe that during 2013 we will feel the brunt of this slowdown to any real degree.   If the slowdown continues into 2014 and beyond then it is likely that it will slow our economy, maybe throwing us into recession as well but not this coming year.  
2.  Europe Muddles Through 
As I’ve discussed on several occasions, Europe’s sovereign debt crisis is not going to end well.  There is no satisfactory solution to their problem.  The only question is when, not if, it will implode.  The Europeans have been doing an excellent job kicking the can down the road these past few years and I’m guessing they will be able to further kick the can down the road through 2013.  If they can there will be little negative consequence this coming year to their sovereign debt crisis on the American economy. 
3.  Fiscal Cliff Outcome 
As of the time of my writing this blog post the Senate has just passed a bill to avoid the fiscal cliff but it has yet to be voted on by the House.  It’s hard to tell if this version will be acceptable to House Republicans.   At some point there will be an agreement, either this bill or one modified slightly to accommodate the House Republicans.  But let me let you in on a little secret, actually a big secret: It makes no difference which side wins the budget negotiation.  What both sides are proposing is equivalent to arranging the deck chairs on the Titanic.  They are haggling over nuance differences over how to raise tax revenues with almost no proposed spending cuts.  The proposed bill will raise about $1 trillion over 10 years.  That’s equal to $100 billion annually, which is an insignificant amount when compared to what is needed to right our fiscal ship.  So instead of having annual deficits of $1.2 trillion, we will have going forward $1.1 trillion in annual deficits.  So in ten years the total U.S. debt will go from $16 trillion to $27 trillion.  Sadly, no one in Washington has the courage to put our fiscal house in order.  Not the president, not the Republicans.  
Now the real question for 2013 is whether or not the stock market and the credit agencies perceive this miserable attempt at political theatrics as the sham that it is.  If not, then it will have no adverse impact on our economy.   If they do, the stock market will start to decline, possibly precipitously, and the credit agencies, such as Standard & Poors, may be forced to further downgrade the credit rating of our country.  That’s the potential fallout from the Fiscal Cliff.   Stay tuned.
If we can avoid these three pitfalls from happening in 2013, then our economy should continue to grow.  And with a growing economy commercial real estate in the Pacific Northwest should do quite well this coming year.   But the bigger issue is finding people on both sides of the aisle who have the political courage to get us out of our fiscal mess.

Saturday, September 29, 2012

QE3 - To Infinity and Beyond!

The recent news from The Federal Reserve reminds me of a saying by Buzz Lightyear. You remember ol' Buzz, the toy astronaut, in the movie series Toy Story. Every time he lept from a piece of furniture, he would proclaim with great fanfare, "To infinity and beyond!!"

That's more or less what Ben Bernanke said recently and I might add with about the same enthusaism. The Fed will try a new round of quantitative easing to jump start the economy. And Mr. Bernanke implied there is no cut off to this third round. He'll do it as long as it takes to get the desired results. Hence, to infinity and beyond is a good interpretation of his policy.

My friend Kevin Geraci of Zions Bank wrote a well written article recently on this subject. I don't normally quote verbatim news articles but I thought his was deserving. So here goes:
 
Two weeks ago, the Federal Reserve announced its third round of quantitative easing, more commonly called QE3, whereby the Fed essentially prints money and then buys assets with it in order to add liquidity to the financial system and bring down interest rates.
 
The ultimate goal of this monetary policy tool is to spur economic growth and lower the unemployment rate—the same promise we got in QE1 and QE2.   Further, the Fed also announced that it is also changing its interest rate forecast and now sees the Fed funds rate remaining exceptionally low through mid-2015 (previously it was late 2014).
 
The announcement of QE3 is wearisome for many and for many reasons.  While the stimulative policies are temporary and artificial, the laws of macro-economics typically are not.  Asset prices have been artificially manipulated and do not reflect long-term economic reality. So what?
 
Two weeks ago, commodity prices rose again as investors sought to hedge themselves against a falling U.S. dollar.  Quantitative easing serves to dilute the money supply still more, and naturally the value of the money declines.  This may be good news if you are an exporting business, but the falling dollar will cause commodities to rise even higher, exactly what we do not need in a recovering economy as essential commodities like food and fuel get much more expensive.
 
The FOMC, of which Ben Bernanke is Chairman, now employs a staff of about 450, about half of whom are Ph.D. economists.  Perhaps that is the problem - the lack of common sense in the ‘monetary market place’.  Perhaps Bernanke should employ a few middle-class workers on his staff as a ‘reality barometer’ to see first hand what is working and what isn’t!
 
And now the Fed states that instead of purchasing customary Treasury Bonds, it is going to purchase large quantities of Agency Mortgages (Fannie, Freddie and Ginnie), up to $40 billion per month worth, in hopes of stabilizing the housing market and creating more jobs.  As if the Government debt situation isn’t bad enough, the Government will own huge pools of 30-year fixed rate agency mortgages that over time (certainly before they mature) will be at interest rates less than the Government’s own Fed funds rate.  Now that is a good investment!
 
Little has taken place in the economy here, and elsewhere in the world for that matter, as a result of QE 1, 2 and likely 3.  Meanwhile, our national debt now exceeds our Gross Domestic Product for the first time since WWII.  So when our creditors start feeling confident enough in their own economies to start cashing in their T-Bills for higher yielding investments, where does our Government get that money?  Or, when our Social Security Fund, the only Federal Budget item that is funded via dedicated funding sources, wants to cash in its Treasury Bonds to pay for your retirement or disability, can we pay them?
 
Is it time to ask the wise men at the FOMC what they're doing?!

 

Friday, August 17, 2012

Fact or Fiction: We're going down!

I just finished reading, Aftershock: Protect Yourself and Profit in the Next Global Financial Meltdown by David Wiedemer, Robert Wiedemer and Cindy Spitzer.  As you can imagine by the title of the book, the authors are not too bullish about our future.  Let me restate that: they are down right pessimistic about our chances of correcting our economic ship.  As far as they're concerned it's not going to happen. We're going down in flames and we're going to pull down the rest of the world with us.  

Now before you go and find a bridge to jump off of, the world will go on, a new economic order will eventually emerge from the ashes and the U.S. will likely lead the way again, this time a whole lot wiser as we learn from the mistakes of the past 30 years that set us on this course in the first place.  That's the gist of the book.  
The question that we need to ask ourselves is: How true are the premises presented in the book that lead to this conclusion?  Are these authors a bunch of nut jobs or do they have valid points? While I don't agree with some of their conclusions, I believe the overall framework that they present is both logical and intuitive. Let's see what you think as I outline the basic premises of their book.

The authors believe that beginning in the early 1980s, with the decision to run large government deficits, six co-linked bubbles have been growing bigger and bigger, each working to lift the others, all booming and supporting the U.S. economy.  A bubble is defined as an asset value that temporarily booms and eventually busts, based on changing investor psychology rather than underlying, fundamental economic drivers that are sustainable over time.  The six bubbles are:

  1. The real estate bubble
  2. The stock market bubble
  3. The private debt bubble
  4. The discretionary spending bubble
  5. The dollar bubble
  6. The government debt bubble
The first four of these bubbles began to burst in late 2008 and 2009 which rocked the U.S. and world economies.  It's kind of difficult to disagree with this premise with maybe the exception of the stock market.  Was the stock market crash of 2008 as a result of a bubble? The authors make a compelling case (which you'll have to read) that the stock market crash of 2008 was in fact a bubble that was not supportable by sound economics.  

The second major premise of the book is that while most people think the worst is over, the coming Aftershock will bring down all six bubbles in the next two to five years.  Whoa!  So what's the evidence to support their view.

The authors go on to explain that money, like all assets, is also affected by the law of supply and demand.  If there are too many dollars available their value falls.  In the past four years The Federal Reserve, in order to avoid a collapse of our economy, has increased the money supply through Quantitative Easing from $800 billion to $2.6 trillion.  This is an unprecedented increase in the money supply. The final bubble to pop is the government debt bubble.  Our national debt in that last four years has increased from $10 trillion to $16 trillion!  Both the dollar bubble and the U.S. government debt bubble have been pumped up to offset the other popping bubbles.  Both are on unsustainable paths and they too will pop bursting America's and the world's economy.  

As I mentioned earlier I don't agree with everything they say in this book.  My fundamental disagreement is in the inevitability of the last two bubbles popping.  If present trends continue, i.e., we continue to avoid making difficult decisions, then I absolutely agree that the dollar and government debt bubbles will pop as predicted.  I also believe that nothing will get done to solve our economic problems until there is a crisis.  

The good news is there is a crisis looming which should get our politicians' attention: Europe.  There is no solution to Europe's debt crisis.  None.  Anyone who thinks otherwise is living in "la la land." Europe's days are numbered.  When they falter, and they will, this catastrophic event should give our political leaders the impetus to make the necessary, painful decisions to keep us from following Europe over the precipice.  Just like the days immediately after 9/11 both political parties will come together for a short period of time.  As Rahm Immanuel once said, "You never want a serious crisis to go to waste."  Let's hope they take advantage of the collapse of Europe to right our economic ship so we can avoid following in their footsteps.    

Friday, February 17, 2012

The Fox & The Scorpion

I recently read a short article by John Stossel of Fox News regarding the enormity of the federal deficit. We’ve all heard news stories about the U.S. debt crisis but for most of us, me included, it’s hard to grasp the magnitude of the problem. So here goes:

Imagine that there’s a family that earns an income of $21,700 a year. But this family spends $38,200 a year. The annual difference between income and expenses of $16,500 is added to their credit card debt. This family has been spending more than it brings in for many years and currently the outstanding balance on their credit card is $152,000. The interest expense on their credit card alone now costs them $4,540 annually or about 21 percent of their total annual income.

The family finally recognizes they have a serious financial problem that cannot go on indefinitely so they sit down together to determine what they can do to balance their budget. After much consideration and wrangling between family members they proudly propose cutting $385 from their spending and declare their efforts a success! It makes no difference to them that a cut of $385 is a pittance of what they need to cut in order to balance their budget. A year later, to their surprise, they actually tally the numbers to discover they spent $362 more than the previous year.

We are them! If you add eight zeros behind each of the numbers identified above that is the situation the U.S. government now faces:

The saddest part about this whole mess is no one who has the power to do anything about this seems to take this situation seriously. I believe the American public thinks that some how we’ll muddle through, that we can just borrow some more money from the Chinese if we need to or if absolutely necessary we can print more money to avoid any embarrassing economic catastrophe. Our day of reckoning can be postponed but it cannot be avoided.

Future generations will look back at us and wonder, “What were they thinking? Where was the leadership needed to avoid this economic crisis?” And before you think I’m going to only lambast the Democrats for profligate spending think again. They may talk a good game but when it comes to spending the Republicans are just as bad as the Democrats! A pox upon both their parties! Together they have spent money like drunken sailors! I know of no politician today who is willing to sacrifice his incumbency to do the right thing. Because believe me when I say this: any politician that is successful in turning this around will be voted out of office in the next election (think the recall of the Wisconsin governor). He or she will be vilified for doing the right thing because those who are feeding at the government trough will not go away quietly. They cannot be reasoned with. They will fight to the death to keep getting their government benefits (think Greek riots).

It reminds me of the story of the fox and the scorpion. The scorpion asks the fox if he can hitch a ride on his back in order to get across the river. The fox says to the scorpion, “But if I carry you on my back what will prevent you from stinging me.” The scorpion replied, “Why would I sting you, we’d both drown.” So the fox says to the scorpion jump on. Half way across the river the scorpion fatally stings the fox. The fox says, “Why did you sting me, we are both going to die.” The scorpion says, “Because it’s in my character to sting you.” And they both drown.

Those who are selfishly gorging themselves on government benefits, whether it’s the retiree who is receiving Social Security checks that are 4 times what he’s paid into the Social Security system or whether its corporate welfare in the form of tax breaks for the multinational corporations and everyone in between, don’t care what they are doing to this country as long as they get their’s. They are the scorpion who kills their free ride not realizing if everyone acts like they do that we’re all going to sink in our country’s enormous debt.

Is anyone listening to me? Does anyone care?

Sources: Dangerous Debt by John Stossel, January 5, 2012; Interest Expense on the Debt Outstanding, treasurydirect.gov