MCF Market Watch


Welcome!


In the interest of keeping our clientele educated and well-informed in a trying economy, MCF issues bi-weekly market assessments.

Go to our web site to subscribe to this and other news and tools, including the MCF Rate Sheet and Mortgage Solutions - Real Quotes On Real Deals (TM).

Follow us online! 


Showing posts with label Financing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Financing. Show all posts

Saturday, November 10, 2012

Timing Is Everything When Financing CRE

They say that, "Timing is everything."  Right?  Well it certainly holds true when it comes to financing commercial real estate.  There are times during the year when trying to get a loan financed is pure misery and there are times when the financing "gods" are looking down benevolently on you.  But let me tell you a little secret: It's not rocket science to figure out when is the optimal time to get things financed.  It's plain common sense.  Shown below are the worst times and then the best times to get your property financed.

Worst Times to Finance CRE

  1. June 10th through Labor Day - If you haven't signed your loan application before summer starts, good luck!  Summer is the time when kids are out of school and family's take long vacations.  Loan officers, underwriters, loan processors, real estate brokers, mortgage brokers, attorneys, appraisers, etc. all lose focus during the summer months and as a result the financing process slows down to a crawl, or so it seems.
  2. November 1st through Year End - If your loan is not expected to close before year end, your deal will go to the bottom of the pile.  All the focus during the end of the year is to work on deals that will close before year end so loan officers can make their quotas and for those who have had a good year, to make their bonuses.
Best Times to Finance CRE
  1. First Quarter - The best time of the year to start the financing process is during the first quarter.  Bankers are refreshed after the holidays and eager to start working on their annual quotas in order to acheive their year end bonuses.  Most insurance companies will be back in the market ready to lend.  As the year progresses, they become more and more selective on property type and quality of transaction.  
  2. Labor Day through October 31st - People are back from vacations, kids are in school, and lenders are again eager to get their last round of deals started for the year so that they close before the holiday season. 
  3. November 1st through the 15th - To paraphrase Charles Dickens, "These are the best of times and the worst of times."  No sane loan officer should commit to closing a loan in less than 60 days.  But those loan officers who haven't reached their quota, or have, but want to increase their bonuses even further go into "warp speed" trying to cram in the final deals for the year.  If the "moon and the stars" line up perfectly or they're just plain lucky they succeed.  I just found out late last week that I have a client that must close his commercial real estate purchase before the end of the year or he will experience adverse tax consequences.  There are less than 50 days to the end of the year and the deal is not yet under application.  I haven't closed a loan this year under 75 days, most have been considerably longer. And yet, I have four lenders who have committed to closing on this deal before year end. This just tells me there are a lot of hungry loan officers who want to get deals closed no matter what it takes. 
So when is the best time to finance commercial real estate?  It's plain common sense: Whenever your loan officer is highly motivated to get the deal done.

Source: The Importance of Luck and Timing in Real Estate, by Kevan McCormack, Metropolitan Capital Advisors

Friday, September 21, 2012

Be Proactive and Anticipate Financing Road Blocks Before they Happen

In the past, a borrower was typically asked to provide a simple financial statement with a credit check, and that was the extent of the credit items required.  Ah, the good old days.  In today’s environment, lenders have upped their borrower documentation considerably requiring an extensive amount of information on the borrower. 

I’m continually surprised by most borrowers who don’t know the necessary documentation they need to provide in order to get a lender interested in them.  They could avoid many of their financing problems if they anticipated the financing road blocks before they happen.  Shown below are seven of the more common examples of issues to watch out for:

1.   Minimum Net Worth to Loan Ratio – Each lender has different requirements but they typically require the borrower’s net worth to be equal to the loan amount.  Some require a borrower’s net worth to be as much as two times the proposed loan amount.  Find out what your lender requires before signing the application.  

2.   Minimum Number of Months of Debt Service Required of Liquid Assets - Again each lender is different but they typically require liquid assets showing on the borrower’s balance sheet equal to 6 to 12 months of debt service.  Find out what your lender requires before signing the application. 

3.   Complete the REO Schedule with all the Details Filled In – Many lenders are now creating a global cash flow spreadsheet on the borrower.  They want to see if the prospective borrower is generating a positive cash flow or slowly draining himself of all his cash.  Much of the detail required to determine his global cash flow comes from the real estate owned schedule.  Prepare the REO schedule before you begin talking to lenders so that when they ask for it, it’s ready for them.  If you need a copy of a REO schedule contact me and I’ll email you one. 

4.   Credit Rating & Explanations of 30 Day Late Payments – Run a credit report on yourself before you start looking for a lender.  Find out your credit score.  Most lenders require that your credit score be a minimum of 680.  If yours is not that high, you better have a good explanation.  Also you need to explain every payment that is 30 days late or more.  Put it in writing before they ask. 

5.   Explain Past Tax Liens, Judgments, Litigation – have written explanations with back up documentation already prepared before you sign the application.  Give the prospective lender your explanations and have him verify in advance of signing your application that your explanations are satisfactory and will not impact loan approval.  Do it before you sign the application when you have the most negotiating power, not after when you have little or none. 

6.   Tax Returns, not just Schedule 1040s, signed and dated including all K-1s – Lenders want all of your federal tax returns, not parts of them.  Typically, most borrowers forget to sign and date their tax returns and most times it takes two or three attempts to get all of their K-1s.  To speed up the process get it done correctly the first time. 

7.   Thoroughly Read the Application and Ask Questions Prior to Signing the Application – It is imperative that you understand every clause in the loan application.  Lenders become frustrated, and rightly so, when borrowers and their legal counsel voice issues at the closing table about lending requirements that were disclosed on the loan application.  Negotiate any onerous lending requirement prior to signing the application.

One of the truest statements ever uttered about commercial real estate is, “Time kills deals.”  A lengthy, drawn out loan underwriting process will at the very least move your deal to the bottom of the pile.  It has the potential of killing the deal altogether.  Many of these seven issues can be avoided if the borrower will be proactive and anticipate what the lender is going to require.  A good borrower, a good mortgage broker should work towards making the lender’s process as easy as possible to avoid ever hearing the words, “I’m sorry to inform you, your loan has been turned down.”  

Source: From the Analyst Chair: Anticipate the Road Blocks in Commercial Real Estate Finance by Metropolitan Capital Advisors Blog, September 4, 2012. 

Saturday, June 9, 2012

Another Questionable Decision by The Federal Reserve

The Federal Reserve last Thursday released a proposal that would implement a global agreement known as Basel III. This agreement is a regulatory standard that proposes minimum capital requirements and liquidity standards for all financial institutions worldwide.

I know what you’re thinking as I was thinking it too: I’m tired of reading another boring article on banking regulations. But I would encourage you not to delete this blog post before you get a “view from 35,000 feet” on how Basel III is going to impact the commercial real estate industry. It could have an enormous adverse impact on our industry if not implemented gradually.

From our perspective the most egregious new implementation being proposed by Basel III is assigning a higher risk weight to commercial real estate loans of 150%, up from a current risk weight of 100%. How does that affect the bank? The more risk, the more capital that’s required by financial institutions to have on hand as a buffer. So the more they lend on commercial real estate the higher their capital requirement. If they lend on other assets, home loans or businesses for example, they will not be required to hold as much in reserve.

So what do you think the banks are going to do when this new rule is fully implemented? Do you think they will lend more or less on commercial real estate? Of course, the tendency will be to lend less. And how do you think in real terms that will be done? I think there will be fewer banks lending on commercial real estate and those that do will find a plethora of ways to make it that much more difficult to get a loan approved and closed (as if we need more banking regulations to slow down the loan approval process).

This isn’t me just “crying wolf.” Fitch Ratings estimated last week that the world’s 29 largest banks will need to raise another $566 billion by the end of 2018 to meet these new international liquidity requirements against risk. Where is that going to come from?

I wonder why they consider commercial real estate so risky? The Great Recession was brought about by a housing bubble and lax underwriting standards for qualifying borrowers of home loans, not because of excesses in the commercial real estate industry. So why pick on us? Why make commercial real estate the scapegoat? The Federal Reserve needs to think this through and figure out what the ramifications are to our economy if this is fully implemented. Basel III ultimately means less lending on commercial real estate which means a slower economy which means fewer people being employed.


I’m all in favor of reforming the banking industry (remember I’m in favor of Dodd Frank) but increasing the risk weight for commercial real estate may be over the top. There’s got to be someone on The Federal Reserve Board of Governors who has enough common sense to understand this and has the courage of his convictions to push back. Don’t you think?

Sources: Basel III, Wikipedia; Fitch Ratings: World's Biggest Banks May Need To Raise $566 to Comply With New International Rules, Huffington Post, June 7, 2012; Fed ups capital buffer for commercial real estate, Market Watch, The Wall Street Journal, June 7, 2012; Federal Reserve unveils Basel III bank capital proposal, The Economic Times, June 8, 2012.
 
 
 

Monday, September 5, 2011

How Bill Gross Got It All Wrong

Earlier this year Bill Gross, the head of bond giant PIMCO, announced in grand fashion that he was getting out of U.S. Treasuries. His reasoning was quite rational: The end of the Fed's quantitative easing program, which ended in June, would be bad for bonds. Prices would fall causing yields (or interest rates) to rise. This would happen because the Fed was the number one buyer of U.S. debt. Without the Fed buying bonds one of two things would have to happen to prevent yields from rising:

  1. Some other country would have to step in to buy the Fed's volume of U.S. Treasuries which was highly unlikely, or
  2. The U.S. government would have to significantly moderate their borrowing to shrink the volume of U.S. Treasuries being sold on the market. At the present time for every $1 spent by the federal government about 40 cents of that amount is borrowed.
So what do you think are the chances of either #1 or #2 happening? Not likely is it? Looking at it from this perspective, it seemed quite unlikely that another country could purchase the enormous quantity of bonds that the Fed had been buying over the last two years. And it also seemed unlikely that the federal government would reduce its need to borrower.

This past week people were crowing about how Bill Gross got it all wrong and how he lost a lot of money for his bond fund investors. He even admitted sheepishly that it had been a "mistake" to get out of U.S. treasuries. Since Mr. Gross’s announcement in March the 10 year treasury rate has plummeted from 3.46% to 2.02% (Sep 2nd). So how does someone of Mr. Gross's caliber get it wrong? What did he miss?

Back in March when Mr. Gross made his announcement there was no way for anyone to predict:
  1. That the sovereign debt crisis in Europe would reach critical mass this year. European leaders had been successful over the years in “kicking the can down the road” and it seemed likely this year would be no different. Wrong!
  2. What the impact of the sovereign debt crisis would have on the U.S. treasury market. Fear of a default of sovereign debt by Greece and then by Italy has caused a panic among Europeans. And when panic ensues, investors take their money out of risky investments promising a return on their money and instead invest in less risky investments, in this case U.S. treasuries, where they focus on getting a return of their money.
What has happened is the law of supply and demand has kicked in. Concerned European investors have dramatically increased the demand for U.S. treasuries while the supply has stayed the same. When that happens, yields decline. It’s really that simple.

But the big question is, “How does this affect those of us in the commercial real estate market?” We are currently seeing historically low interest rates.  A lower interest rate means a lower mortgage payment which means better cash flows after debt service. If you own commercial real estate now is the time to lock in long term fixed rate financing.

I know I sound like the boy who cried wolf one too many times but some day we are all going to wake up and the world will be different. Some unpredictable catastrophic event will have occurred (a run on U.S. banks perhaps) causing interest rates to skyrocket and when that happens those who had the foresight to lock in the low rates will be the big winners.

Source: Bill Gross and the Case for Buy Low and Hold, Morgan Housel, The Motley Fool, August 31, 2011.

Tuesday, May 24, 2011

Exposing the Soft Underbelly of the Beast

For those of us who believe the Federal Reserve, Wall Street and the major financial institutions in this country wield too much power, something recently happened that has me baffled. 

In March the US Securities and Exchange Commission requested a few of the regional banks to clarify their loan modification policies, what we call in the business "extend and pretend."  Last month the Financial Accounting Standards Board (better known as FASB) also got into the act by issuing new accounting guidelines for "troubled debt restructurings" (TDRs).

On the surface the new accounting guidelines for troubled assets seems quite reasonable.  FASB wants to standardize the definition of what constitutes a TDR so all financial institutions are operating under the same rules.  Right now that isn't happening.  In order to determine if the restructuring is a TDR, a lender must separately conclude that both the borrower is experiencing financial difficulties and the restructuring constitutes a concession.

Beginning June 15th lenders must re-examine their restructured debt to determine how much of it qualifies to be a TDR.  If so, the lender must classify it as such.  The end result is that for the very first time we will see how much of a lender's loan portfolio is deemed "troubled."  At the present time, lending institutions have been able to hide their TDRs with the hope that one day the market will turn around and the loans will be refinanced at market rates and terms, or better yet paid off in full. 

The new accounting rules could have enormous implications, most of which fall in the range between bad and catastrophic.  At the very least the number of loans classified as troubled debt will rise dramatically throughout the banking industry.  But the big question is, "Will the general public's confidence in a bank's solvency be adversely affected?"  Once the cat is out of the bag will the stronger financial institutions be reluctant to transact business with their weaker brothers?

Which leads me back to my original thought: Why did the SEC and the FASB do this?  If you believe like I do (most days) that the Federal Reserve, Wall Street and the major financial institutions wield way too much power, why would they allow these new TDR accounting guidelines to be implemented?  This is not in their best interests.  The change in these accounting rules has the potential of exposing the truth that they desperately want to keep hidden from the public - most banks are hopelessly insolvent.  This only helps to expose their true predicament.

The huge bank bailouts by both the Bush and Obama administrations, the extend and pretend lending policies of the banks, and the historically low interest rates by the Federal Reserve have all been implemented to directly benefit the financial institutions of this country.  So why are they now exposing the soft underbelly of the beast?  If you have an explanation, I'd like to hear it.

Sources: The Extend and Pretend Expose' - coming to a bank near you, ft.com/alphaville by Tracy Halloway, May 20, 2011; More Transparency Coming to Hidden Costs of 'Extend and Pretend' Strategies, CoStar Group by Mark Heschmeyer, May 18, 2011. 

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

1st Quarter 2011 Transaction Activity

The first quarter of 2011 is over.  From a sales standpoint how well did we do compared to previous years?  Shown below is the criteria we used to tabulate the results:

  • Sales information from the CoStar Group database
  • Transactions closed between January 1st and March 31st
  • Investment transactions only (no owner occupied)
  • Property types - apartments, office, flex, industrial, retail, mixed use & specialty use
  • Transactions with sales prices of $1 million or larger
  • Arms length transactions only
  • Transactions located between Kelso, WA and Eugene, OR including Bend
Based on this criteria the chart shown below compares the sales activity for the 1st quarter for each of the last five years:


 
As you can see, the sale activity for the first quarter of 2011 increased significantly over 2010 but fell well below previous years.  The good news is that if this trend continues for the rest of this year, 2010 will have been the bottom of the market with a good possibility of improving sales activity going forward.   


We then analyzed the 45 sales transactions for the first quarter by property type.

As you can see apartments still are the most favored property type with 42 percent of the sales in the first quarter followed by retail.  Most of the retail sales were fast food franchises or single tenant buildings. 

Of the 45 sales transactions, only 35 identified the broker representation and only 38 identified the lending source used.  The remaining transactions did not provide sufficient information to determine the lender or if brokers were involved in the transactions.

Another way of looking at it, there were 45 paydays for all of the real estate brokers in the first quarter (17 x 2 = 34 + 7 +4 = 45).  So if you know how many of these transactions you were involved in, you can determine your market share. 

Shown below are the first quarter lending sources for the 38 sales transactions that a lender was identified.


Almost half of all sales transactions in the first quarter did not need new financing.  These results also explode the myth that life companies are back in the market.   After you take away the all cash buyers and assumed loans only 20 loans were placed in the first quarter, most of these from banks.  This paltry number of loans for the first quarter does not bode well for the mortgage brokerage community but hopefully we are on an improving trend.  I look forward to seeing how this quarter turns out.  Keep your fingers crossed.

Tuesday, January 4, 2011

My Crystal Ball Forecast for 2011 Commercial Real Estate

Doug Marshall, CCIM
Market Assesment


Back in December I asked my reading audience to give their opinions about what the commercial real estate market would look like in 2011.

I was pleasantly surprised by the number of people who responded. Thank you. Generally those who responded had similar thinking about the coming year as I did. So here goes:

· It’s the economy stupid! Everything hinges on what the economy ends up doing. The good news is that the economy is on the upswing. I know it doesn’t feel that way but the economy is on the rebound, albeit ever so slowly.

Believe it or not, we have had five consecutive quarters of positive growth in the GDP averaging just under 3% annually. Job growth is a different matter. There has been virtually no real improvement in the unemployment rate during this time period, currently stuck at 9.8% nationally.

The recent compromise tax bill maintaining the Bush era tax rates for another two years and lowering the payroll tax by 2 percent will have a positive impact on the economy. So I’m expecting a modest improvement in the overall economy by the end of the year.

· Rising interest rates. No one expects interest rates to stay at the current level. We are all predicting them to rise, the only question is how much. If they rise gradually over time we’ll be OK. If they rise dramatically over a short period of time, like they did from early October through mid December of 2010, it will shut down our industry until real estate prices adjust to the higher rates.

The consensus is that rates will rise slowly. Let’s hope we’re right. The alternative would be disastrous

· Will there be more lenders in the market? Yes. Absolutely. And their rates will be more competitive too. I am beginning to see this especially for apartment financing. I get calls from lenders saying that they plan to dramatically increase their loan volume in 2011 and asking what they need to do with their rates and terms to get more deals.

I also see a few lenders getting back in the retail side of the market. Lenders are showing more interest but underwriting will continue to be difficult. I think there will be more lenders in the market as their balance sheets improve. We are not over the banking crisis but we are beginning to see a light at the end of the tunnel.

· What property types will show increased sales in 2011 over the prior year? Everyone agrees there will be increased sales transactions in 2011. That’s probably because to be in commercial real estate you have to be a cockeyed optimist!

However there wasn’t a consensus as to which property types will show the most improvement. This is my take: I believe all property types except for land and hotels will show improved sales activity this year.

However for most property types, office, retail and industrial, the properties that are distressed with blood in the water will be in demand and those that are strong credit tenant properties will also be in demand. Everything in between will likely have very little sales activity.

Lenders have shown little appetite for properties that have any “hair” on them whatsoever, i.e., high vacancy, rental rates trending down, short lease terms, etc. Apartments, being the exception will do fine regardless of size, condition, and location as there are several lenders wanting to finance apartments with more recently coming into the market.

· Where are vacancy rates, concessions and rental rates heading? Improvement in vacancy rates, concessions and rental rates will be dependent on job growth, especially for office and industrial properties. Apartments and retail are less dependent on job growth but they too would show improved demand if the unemployment rate were to dip a bit.

The unemployment rates for Oregon and Washington, 10.6% and 8.9% respectively are not expected to improve significantly this year. At best I think we will see modest improvement in the unemployment rate, but probably not enough to affect real estate values.

· What will cap rates do? I think rising interest rates will stop any fall we might have seen in cap rates due to improving fundamentals and demand. They will counterbalance one another.

I believe it is possible that the top of the line properties may see some improvement in cap rates but all other properties will see either have a flat or slightly rising cap rate during the year.

A special thanks to Mike Baron, Mark Barry, Charles Conrow, Tom Davis, Alan Evans, Tom Hanacek, Cliff Hockley, Steve Morris, Marc Rogers, Dan Rodriguez, and Christian Trandum who gave valuable input for this article.

Thursday, September 9, 2010

Banks On The Rebound

Doug Marshall, CCIM
Market Assessment



Second quarter banking results show strong evidence that U.S. banks are beginning to dig themselves out of the big hole they’ve been wallowing in for the past three years.

Among some of the rosier statistics are:

  • The FDIC second quarter numbers showing 90-plus day delinquencies leveling off and eventually set to decline because 30-89 day delinquencies are declining. Also, net charge-offs are leveling off too.
  • The banking industry’s quarterly earnings of $21.6 billion are up dramatically from a year ago loss of -$4.4 billion and represent the highest quarterly earnings since the third quarter 2007.
  • Sixty-five percent of the banks are reporting higher year-over-year quarterly net income.
  • Loan loss reserves are showing improvement as insured institutions added $40.3 billion in provisions to their loan loss allowances in the second quarter. While still high by historic standards, this is the smallest total since the industry set aside $37.2 billion in the first quarter of 2008.

“Without question, the industry still faces challenges. Earnings remain low by historical standards, and the number of unprofitable institutions, problem banks and failures remains high,” says FDIC chairman Sheila C Bair.

“But the banking sector is gaining strength. Earnings have grown, and most asset quality indicators are moving in the right direction.”

Regionally, Sterling Savings Bank has been successful in raising the required funds to stay in business while Bank of the Cascades has asked for another extension.

Having both of these banks come back from their death beds would be encouraging to a Pacific Northwest economy that has been slow to recover.

From our perspective at Marshall Commercial Funding, we are witnessing a number of lenders coming back into the market in the last few months, some with very favorable rates and terms.

It’s too soon to say the banking crisis is over but it is encouraging to see the baby steps being taken in the right direction.

Sources:
U.S. Banks Report CRE Loan Troubles Subsiding Amid Strong Quarterly Earnings, CoStar Group, September 8, 2010;
Sterling Financial hits $730M investment goal, Portland Business Journal, August 28, 2010;
Bank of the Cascades gets another extension, Portland Business Journal, July 16, 2010.

Sunday, August 8, 2010

Who’s Financing Transactions for the First Six Months of 2010?

Doug Marshall, CCIM
Market Assessment


In my last market assessment we analyzed the transaction activity for the first 6 months of 2010 compared to previous years.

This information was taken from the CoStar database for transactions above $1 million, for investment properties (no owner occupied) and for the geographic area from Kelso to Eugene along the I-5 corridor including Bend.

To summarize, there were a total of 59 sales transactions for the first half of this year; transaction activity peaked in 2007 at 251 and has stair stepped downward each subsequent year to where we are today. This represents a 76% reduction in sales activity since 2007.

For more details on the sales activity in our geographic area since 2006 I encourage you to read my last market assessment.

Of the 59 transactions closed in the first half of 2010, 51 transactions identified the lender. Shown below is a summary of these lending sources:







All Cash Buyers

17

33%



Loans Assumed

2

4%



Local/Regional Banks

7

14%



National Banks

10

20%



Fannie Mae

6

12%



Seller Financed

9

18%




51

100%







There are a couple interesting tidbits from this data: 1) 54% of the transactions did not require conventional financing; they were either all cash buyers, the existing loans were assumed or seller financing was used; and 2) there were no life company loans, which refutes the myth that the life companies are actively seeking loans. If they are, it doesn’t show up in the data.

Another tidbit of information from the sales activity that you may find of interest is broker representation.

Of the 59 transactions, 48 identified the broker’s involved; eleven did not provide sufficient information to know if there was broker representation in the transaction. But of the 48 transactions that provided information on broker involvement this is how it broke out:







Both sides represented

29

60%



No buyer's broker

11

23%



No brokers involved

8

17%




48

100%







In other words, there were 69 paydays (29 x 2 + 11) for the brokerage community in the first half of 2010. It will be interesting to compare 2011 transactions with this year’s sales activity.

A year from now will we look back and see that we have turned a corner? For all of our sakes, I hope so.

Friday, July 9, 2010

How to Get the Best Possible Loan for Your Property

Doug Marshall, CCIM
Market Assessment

You have three basic options to consider when shopping for a commercial mortgage loan. You can choose to:

  1. Finance your property with a lender you already do business with,
  2. Shop the mortgage market on your own, or,
  3. Employ the services of a commercial mortgage broker to shop the market.

For most property owners the option that significantly improves your chances of getting the best possible loan for your property is using the services of a mortgage broker.

As self-serving at that may sound, come to your own conclusion as you review the advantages and disadvantages of each option discussed below.


Option #1 – Finance your property with your existing lender
Convenience is the primary advantage of financing your property with a lender you currently do business with. It certainly is the path of least resistance and in most cases it should be the quickest way to get the job done.

The disadvantage of this approach is that you will never know whether you received the best rates and terms currently in the market. The likelihood is that another lender will be more competitive than your current lender.


Option #2 – Shop the mortgage market on your own
The advantage of this option is that you have a higher probability of finding better loan terms than financing your property with your existing lender.

The disadvantage is that it will take considerably more time and effort on your part. If you take this option I have these suggestions for you:

1. Hunt down the most competitive lenders
Contact commercial real estate professionals (real estate brokers, appraisers, escrow officers, etc) or other owners of commercial real estate who can recommend lenders for you to contact.

2. Contact several lenders for loan quotes
To do this correctly you should put together a preliminary loan package that includes at a minimum the following documentation:


a. Two years plus the current YTD operating history on the property,
b. A current rent roll,
c. Photos of the property,
d. Personal financial statements on the borrowers,
e. Two years of personal tax returns, and
f. A brief resume on the owners

Ask each lender to provide you their loan quote in writing. Fight the urge to accept a loan quote over the phone. A loan quote over the phone is meaningless. Get it in writing.

3. Let Lender A know that Lender B has a better loan quote
It is
not uncommon, even in today’s lending environment, that if a lender knows they don't have the best quote on the table that they will go back to their underwriter and see if they can tweak the quote to make it more competitive.

Asking for an improvement in a loan quote should be done tactfully. If done in a heavy-handed manner it will only irritate the lenders which may backfire.

4. Do not focus too heavily on one loan parameter
Often times a borrower chooses the lender that they consider best based on one particular “hot button.” There is nothing wrong with this approach, but a better approach is to review the pros and cons of each loan quote and then decide.

It is not uncommon that when comparing the loan quotes in detail, another lender is chosen rather than the one originally considered the borrower’s first choice.

5. Do not dribble the loan documentation to the lender
Once you have chosen your lender, one of the most important recommendations I can give you is to make the loan process as easy as possible for the lender. You do this by completing the lender’s forms quickly, thoroughly and accurately.

A borrower who is unwilling to focus on getting the forms to the lender in a timely manner is putting the loan at risk.

6. Do not violate the “golden rule” of lending
...
Which is, “He who has the gold makes the rules.” Each lender has its own unique way of underwriting, processing and closing loans. Don’t get into an argument about their process. Provide them with what they are asking for and you’ll be better off in the end.


Option #3 – Employ the services of a commercial mortgage broker to shop the market
There are four distinct advantages of taking this option:

  • The primary advantage of using a mortgage broker is that they know which lenders have the most competitive rates. It’s their job to know.
  • Compared to shopping the market on your own, this option takes significantly less time and effort on the part of the owner. Much of the “heavy lifting” of finding the right lender and processing of the loan is performed by the mortgage broker, not by you.

  • Establishing trust between the borrower and the lender is a vital component to insure a successful loan outcome. If you’ve never worked with a particular lender, a trust relationship has not been established.

    On the other hand, a commercial mortgage broker may have worked on several loans with this lender.

    They know each other. They know each others idiosyncrasies and because of their prior relationship there is a higher probability of getting the loan closed with a mortgage broker than by you going directly to the same lender.

  • There are times in the loan process where you need someone to be your advocate, someone who strenuously defends your best interests. This can best be accomplished by a mortgage broker who has an established relationship with the lender.

    The lender’s loan officer inadequately fills this role as they work for the lender. They are being paid by the lender. Whose best interest do you think they are looking after?

The disadvantage of this option is that it may cost you an additional fee or a slightly higher interest rate for using the services of a mortgage broker, but it may not. It just depends on the lender.

If you decide to use a mortgage broker I have these suggestions for you:

  1. Do not interview residential mortgage brokers. Do not consider using the services of a residential mortgage broker as they do not have the expertise to finance commercial real estate.

  2. Interview more than one commercial mortgage broker. Get two or three recommendations for commercial mortgage brokers to interview. Prepare several questions ahead of time.

    Through the course of the interview find out whether you can trust them, whether they are competent and whether they are likeable. Finish your interview with this question: How are you different than your competition? Then choose one, and only one.

  3. Do not use more than one commercial mortgage broker. When a borrower uses the services of more than one mortgage broker without their knowledge, all trust between borrower and broker evaporates.

    If Mortgage Broker A calls their lending sources and finds out that Mortgage Broker B has already talked to one or more of their favorite lenders, do you think Mortgage Broker A is going to work as hard on this loan request? Not a chance.

  4. Request a side-by-side comparison of loan quotes. A good mortgage broker will get you multiple quotes and then show them in a side-by-side comparison. At the top of the page will be Lender A, Lender B, Lender C, etc.

    Down the page will be all the loan parameters a borrower needs to know in order to make an informed decision, such as loan amount, interest rate, loan term, amortization, loan fee, other financing costs, type of prepayment penalty, cash required at closing or estimated cash back on a refinance, before and after tax cash-on-cash return, to name just a few.

    This side-by-side comparison of the loan quotes makes it much easier to choose the lender that best meets your particular needs.


Whichever of these three options you ultimately choose depends on which advantages and disadvantages are most important to you.

However, I firmly believe that a mortgage broker’s counsel can help a borrower avoid serious pitfalls when shopping for a loan.

A wise man once said, “Plans fail for lack of counsel, but with many advisers they succeed.” That is why an owner optimizes his chances of getting the best possible loan for his property when employing the services of a commercial mortgage broker.

Tuesday, June 22, 2010

Thoughts from a Commercial Mortgage Broker: Eight Ways to Help Close Your Deal

Doug Marshall, CCIM
Market Assessment


In today’s commercial real estate environment it is imperative that we do everything we can to get the few deals that are out there closed.

We certainly don’t want to be the cause for a sales transaction going sideways and yet many times we can inadvertently put a deal at risk.

Shown below are eight ways a real estate broker can help his chances of his deal closing.

  1. Listing brokers, use realistic pro forma numbers in your marketing packages. Good, solid numbers that can be supported by the historical operating statements makes everyone’s job (buyer’s broker, appraiser, mortgage broker and lender) that much easier.

  2. Listing brokers, accept the responsibility of getting property documentation from the seller into a format that is acceptable to the buyer. Without good property documentation the decision to buy is put at risk.

    The goal should be to make it as easy as possible for the buyer to agree to buy the property.

    Once the deal is accepted by the buyer, the property documentation used to get the buyer to say “yes” then helps the appraiser and the lender do their jobs.

  3. Buyer’s broker, get involved in assisting the client with choosing the mortgage broker/lender. As a broker, you are perceived as knowledgeable when you can recommend a competent mortgage broker to assist your client. It also increases your probability of getting paid.

  4. Buyer’s broker, communicate regularly with the other real estate professionals (mortgage broker, lender, escrow officer, appraiser, etc.) that are working to close the transaction. We are all on the same team. The buyer’s broker should consider himself the “quarterback” leading his team to the finish line.

  5. Use realistic deadlines in the sales agreement. A good mortgage broker can assist you in determining reasonable timelines for when the loan will be approved and when it will close.

  6. Be proactive about the issues, not reactive. A good real estate broker anticipates what the issues are going to be and then presents his rationale with sound documentation that mitigates these issues.

  7. Buyer’s broker, encourage the borrower to get his personal loan documentation into the lender quickly, thoroughly and accurately. Again, the goal should be to make the loan process as easy as possible so that the lender can get it approved.

  8. Don’t violate the “Golden Rule” of lending which is, “He who has the gold makes the rules.” Accept that the lender has a process they must follow. Your job is to help the mortgage broker/lender get the loan approved so we can all get paid.



A special thanks to Jerry Aalfs, Tom Bradley, Tom Fischer and Liz Tilbury who gave valuable input on this article.

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Much Ado About Fannie and Freddie

Doug Marshall, CCIM
Market Assessment


From time to time I quote a well-written article verbatim. This is one of those times.

I found this insightful article on the Globe St. com blog discussing what’s currently happening with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. It was written by Sule Aygoren Carranza
who is the New York City-based editor of the Real Estate Forum and multifamily editor for GlobeSt.com.

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Earlier this week, Senate Democrats voted down a bill that would have essentially dissolved Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac after their conservatorship period was over.

Introduced by Senate Republicans John McCain (AZ), Judd Gregg (NH) and Richard Shelby (AL), the amendment to the financial regulatory reform package would have taken the GSEs off of taxpayer support and mapped out a plan to wind down and dissolve them over 15 years.

At the same time, both GSEs in the past few days have reported substantial first-quarter losses due to continued weakness in the market. Freddie Mac posted a $6.7-billion net loss, up $2 billion from the prior quarter and down from $10 billion the same period a year ago.

Fannie Mae’s first-quarter loss came in at $11.5 billion, down from $15.2 billion in the final three months of 2009 and $23.2 billion in the first quarter. The losses were attributed to credit-related expenses and the impact of new accounting standards.

These losses resulted in a net worth deficit of $10.5 billion for Freddie and $8.4 billion for Fannie, for which the companies requested a combined $19 billion in additional funding from the Treasury in order to continue operations. If accepted, that would bring the GSEs’ total federal bailout to some $140 billion.

The good news for multifamily, though, is that the agencies’ losses were primarily on the single-family and guarantee segments of their business.

On the multifamily end, Freddie earned $221 million in the first quarter and Fannie earned $99 million. Those figures are minuscule in comparison to the billion in losses, but they’re better than nothing.

Another bright spot is that the delinquency rate for both firms. Freddie’s monthly delinquency rate fell for the first time in three years, to 4.13% in March (down from 4.2% in February) for single-family homes and 0.24% for multifamily, down one basis point from February.

Meanwhile, Fannie’s serious delinquency rate (that is, loans that were more than 90 days late) rose from 5.38% in the final quarter of 2009 to 5.47% in Q1. Although it registered an increase, Fannie officials said the figures show a slowing growth rate of delinquencies.

The improvement reflects the willingness of lenders to do workouts with borrowers, but with the continued weakness in the economy and the number of underwater mortgages out there growing, I don’t see how this could be a long-lasting trend.

It’s safe to say Congress is stuck between a rock and a hard place. On one hand, the mortgage giants played a large role in the housing market’s downturn and the bailouts, which have been sharply criticized, seem to be growing.

On the other hand, it’s no question that financial support from both Fannie and Freddie is also the primary—if not sole—reason the housing market hasn’t completely imploded.


Source:
Much Ado About Fannie & Freddie, Globe St.com Blog by Sule Aygoren Carranza, May 14, 2010
.