MCF Market Watch


Welcome!


In the interest of keeping our clientele educated and well-informed in a trying economy, MCF issues bi-weekly market assessments.

Go to our web site to subscribe to this and other news and tools, including the MCF Rate Sheet and Mortgage Solutions - Real Quotes On Real Deals (TM).

Follow us online! 


Showing posts with label Greece. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Greece. Show all posts

Saturday, June 23, 2012

Surprise, Surprise, Surprise! Banks Downgraded

In my May 25th blog post I wrote:

"Are the U.S. financial institutions prepared for what is happening in Greece? The answer is, "It depends on which banks you're talking about."  The vast majority of the American banks have no exposure whatsoever to the Greek financial crisis with the exception of our very largest banks - Bank of America, Citigroup, J.P. Morgan Chase, Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs and Wells Fargo.  These six banks have definite exposure to what's happening in Greece.  All reports say that their exposure to Greek insolvency is manageable.  If you want to believe what the banks are telling you then we have nothing to be concerned about.  Call me a cynic, call me a "glass half-empty type of guy, but I don't believe it."

Last Thursday, Moody's cut the credit ratings of 15 of the world's largest financial institutions including five out of the top six largest banks in the U.S. - Bank of America, Citigroup, J.P. Morgan Chase, Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs.  As Gomer Pyle would say, "Surprise, surprise, surprise!" 

Why were they downgraded?  Reasons given were:

  • Marginal liquidity
  • Exposure to the European debt and banking crisis
  • Unspecified volatility and risk management problems in their capital markets activities
How will a lower credit rating affect these banks?
  • It will make it more expensive for them to borrow money.
  • It will make it more difficult to sell their commercial paper to money market funds.
  • It will likely require them to increase their capital requirements.
  • It will likely have an adverse affect on the value of their publicly traded stock.
Did Moody's consider all 15 banks equally in trouble?  No.  Moody's grouped the 15 institutions into three categories based on their relative credit-worthiness.
  • The strongest group had solid capital buffers and "contained" exposure to the European crisis.  J.P. Morgan Chase falls into this category.
  • The second group had varying risk factors, ranging from high dependence on capital markets operations to limited liquidity and exposure to Europe.  Goldman Sachs was in this category.
  • The weakest group had experienced problems with volatility and risk management, and in some cases had weaker buffers than their peers in the industry.  Bank of America, Citigroup & Morgan Stanley were in this category.
Bank of America and Citigroup's credit rating are now rated two notches about junk status, while Morgan Stanley is three notches above. 

Are the credit agencies done downgrading the world's largest financial institutions?  Not even close.  Most of the European banks have been downgraded on several occasions over the past few years and I suspect that further downgrading of our largest banks will continue unless drastic improvement occurs over the next couple of years. 

It is hard for me to believe that one or more of these major U.S. banks will not falter and eventually collapse of its own bad decision making.  The real question is not if it will happen, but when, and more importantly whether those in authority at The Federal Reserve and U.S. Treasury Department have a comprehensive plan to contain the fallout when this occurs.  I suspect that they do have a plan and I suspect that they hope that they don't have to implement it.  That and $1.65 will get you a tall cup of coffee at Starbucks.   

Sources: Major banks downgraded by Moody's, @CNNMoneyInvest, by James O'Toole, June 21, 2002; A Sober New Reality in Credit Downgrades for Banks, DealBook, NYTimes edited by Andrew Ross Sorkin, June 22, 2012.

Friday, May 25, 2012

What's the Rational Thing to Do in a Bank Run?

Something significant happened last week in Europe that I’m guessing most of my readers overlooked. Ever since the debt crisis hit Europe three years ago, Europe has fallen into very predictable cycle. The cycle goes like this:

  • Phase 1 – A financial crisis emerges.
  • Phase 2 – After dire public warnings that the world as we know it will come to an end if something isn’t done immediately a meeting of European leaders is held.
  • Phase 3 – The meeting is met with hope and trepidation, followed by great relief that an agreement has been reached.
  • Phase 4 – Within a few days of the meeting, possibly as long as month, the apparent solution is exposed for what it is: “a band aid for a gaping wound” and the solution unravels.
Last week this cycle was broken. O yes it began exactly the same way. A crisis loomed: What was to be done with Greece? And Phase 2 kicked in, European leaders met. But this is where the cycle stopped. No alternative was found to solve the crisis. And maybe this is a good thing. Maybe, finally, European leaders are realizing that there is no solution to Greece. It’s kind of like an alcoholic who finally admits to himself he has a drinking problem. Until that happens he has no chance whatsoever of living a life of sobriety.
And now that the European leaders admit that there is no solution to the Greek’s financial problems they can now move onto the next phase which is, “How do we allow Greece to leave the eurozone that will minimize the damage?” It is no longer a question of if the Greeks will leave the eurozone it is only a matter of how to do it so that it minimizes the negative consequences from such an event.
And negative consequences there will be. Even now there is a run on the Greek banks. It reminds me of what happened to Washington Mutual a couple of years ago. One moment it was a healthy going concern and within a couple of weeks depositors had electronically pulled out all their deposits from the bank. What is the rational thing to do in a bank run? The rational thing to do is to participate. And that is what’s happening right now with the Greek banks and there is nothing anyone can do about it. The Greek people aren’t stupid. They’re transferring their money into other currencies that have less risk. It’s way too late for the Greek banks to recover.
The really important question is, “Are U.S. financial institutions prepared for what is happening in Greece?” The answer is “It depends on which banks you’re talking about.”
The vast majority of the American banks have no exposure whatsoever to the Greek financial crisis with the exception of our very largest banks – Bank of America, Citigroup, J.P. Morgan Chase, Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs and Wells Fargo. These six banks have definite exposure to what’s happening in Greece. All reports say that their exposure to Greek insolvency is manageable. If you want to believe what the banks are telling you then we have nothing to be concerned about. Call me a cynic, call me a “glass half-empty” type of guy if you like, but I don’t believe it.
Months ago I reported that American financial institutions had only modest amounts of European sovereign debt but they had significantly more risk with credit default swap exposure. A CDS is just a fancy way of saying that they are insuring those who own sovereign debt that it will not default. For a nice fee they are exposed to enormous risk if they are wrong. I believe this is what happened to J.P. Morgan Chase a couple of weeks ago. They bet wrong and voila, they lost $3 billion. Until Congress outlaws these risky forms of investments all bets are off that these six banks will come out of this crisis unscathed.

Sources: Greece and Banks by David Knox, Cumberland Advisors, May 23, 2012; The Rational Thing To Do In A Bank Run, GK Research, May 17, 2012; A Cycle of European Crisis Management, STRATFOR, May 25, 2012.