What’s Going On With Interest Rates?

by Doug Marshall, CCIM
Market Assessment

Over the past 60 days, the yields on 10-year Treasury notes have increased from 2.41% on October 8th to 3.53% as of December 15th, an increase of 1.12%.

What's going on?

Let's begin with a US Bonds 101 class. The 10-year Treasury note has become the security most frequently quoted when discussing the performance of the U.S. government bond market and is used to convey the market's take on longer-term macroeconomic expectations.

All of the marketable Treasury securities are very liquid and are heavily traded on the secondary market. The treasury yield expresses the relationship between the face value of the security and the amount of return the investor receives.

If there are more investors selling bonds then those who are buying bonds, the value of the bond declines (the law of supply and demand). A reduced price on the bond results in an increase in the yield or return on the bond.

Another name for “treasury yield” is “interest rate” which those of us in commercial real estate follow very closely. When US Treasury rates jump up significantly, like they have since early October, it means that investors are dumping their bonds in huge quantities. I can’t recall the last time I’ve seen interest rates jump so dramatically over such a short period of time.

So the $64,000 question is, “Why are bond holders selling off their bonds?” I have surfed the web for an answer to this question and unfortunately there is no agreement among the experts.

Depending on who you like to read there are a variety of answers. But being fearless and little bit stupid I am going to give you my opinion (take it for what it’s worth).

But before I give you my assessment of the situation let me muddy the waters a bit with some conflicting information.

Data released by the Treasury Department yesterday indicated that the Federal Reserve, China and Japan have recently been on a U.S. bond buying binge. The Fed is now owns $972 billion in Treasury holdings which surpasses China’s $906 billion (now the 2nd largest hold of U.S. treasuries).

And with more Quantitative Easing 2 purchases on the horizon it is highly probable that this lead will be greatly extended.

At the very same time, the debt crisis in Europe with what has happened in Greece and Ireland is continuing. Adding to the problem, on Tuesday Moody’s downgraded Spain’s sovereign debt causing further turmoil in the bond market. There is a very real debt crisis going on in Europe which is resulting in European investors transferring their wealth into (you guessed it) U.S. treasuries.

So in recent weeks bond purchases have been exceptionally strong by the major holders of U.S. debt and by the Europeans concerned with their own debt crisis but not nearly enough to offset all the little guys out there who own bonds and who are running scared.

Why are they running scared? There are two reasons that I think make the most sense

1. The Fed’s policy of QE2 is not working as planned. The printing of money by the U.S. Treasury and the purchase of these bonds by The Fed is perceived by the holders of bonds to be inflationary which makes their modest fixed yields less desirable if inflation is going to come roaring back
2. The other issue spooking bondholders that’s surfaced recently is the possible agreement by the Obama administration and Congress about extending the Bush era tax rates for another two years.
   

The compromise between the White House and Republicans included extending employment benefits for another 13 months which combined with extending the existing tax rates will increase the national debt by another trillion dollars. This means the U.S. Treasury will need to issue more bonds to cover the debt.

That being said, I believe that Ben Bernanke will do everything in his power to calm the bond market. What tricks he still has in his bag is anyone’s guess but he will do whatever he can to avoid runaway inflation.

Stay tuned. It’s beginning to get interesting.

Sources:
Fed Surpasses China in Treasury Binge, The Street by Eric Rosenbaum, December 15, 2010;
United States Treasury Securities, Wikipedia;
Bond Prices Fall Sharply after Federal Reserve Says It Will Continue to Boost Economy, The Associated Press, December 14, 2010.

What the heck is Quantitative Easing?

Doug Marshall, CCIM
Market Assessment

If you’ve listened to the news or read a newspaper in recent weeks there is a new buzz phrase being bandied about: Quantitative Easing. So what is it?

The term Quantitative Easing (QE) describes a form of monetary policy used by The Federal Reserve to increase the supply of money in an economy when the bank interest rate, discount rate and/or interbank interest rate are either at, or close to, zero.

The Federal Reserve does this by first crediting its own account with money it has created ex nihilo ("out of nothing") or some would say, by “printing money.” It then purchases financial assets, including government bonds and corporate bonds, from banks and other financial institutions in a process referred to as open market operations.

The purchases, by way of account deposits, give banks the excess reserves required for them to create new money by the process of deposit multiplication from increased lending in the fractional reserve banking system. The increase in the money supply thus stimulates the economy.

What is the purpose of Quantitative Easing?

The Federal Reserve has been given two mandates:

1. It is charged with ensuring full employment in the United States; and,

2. It is also charged with ensuring price stability. Inflation, in recent months, as measured by the CPI (Consumer Price Index), has declined to almost zero which is well below its target of two percent annually.

The Fed hopes that QE will stimulate the economy and thereby ease unemployment.

The Fed also hopes QE will bring the U.S. closer to its stated long-term inflation target.

The primary risk of QE is that it can spark inflation greater than desired or even hyperinflation. Or it could have no impact whatsoever.

Ben Bernanke, Chairman of the Federal Reserve, may be the “smartest guy in the room” but when he’s tweaking the largest economy in the world it is near impossible to really know what the impact The Fed policies will have on the economy.

What has been the impact of Quantitative Easing so far?

The first round of Quantitative Easing took place at the height of the financial crisis in late 2008 and early 2009. What impact did QE have on the economy and interest rates? Good question. I’m not sure anyone knows for sure.

Just recently the Federal Open Market Committee announced another round of Quantitative Easing called QE2. The Fed plans to purchase over $600 billion of long-dated Treasury securities over a period ending in June 2011.

Economists are debating what impact QE2 will have on interest rates. Ted Jones, PhD, Chief Economist for Stewart Title, says it has already significantly increased interest rates and uses the following table to support his position.

The table details the changes in constant-maturity Treasury rates since August 1, 2010. While rates are still comparably low, they have risen significantly in recent weeks.

As noted below in the table three-year Treasury yields are up 80 percent from the low just two weeks ago while two-year notes are up 60 percent. Even the 30-year Treasury yield has jumped 24+ percent since the end of August.

As convincing as this table is in supporting Dr. Jones’s opinion, I don’t think anyone can know for sure if the recent rise in interest rates can be directly attributed to the announced purchase of $600 billion of treasury securities over the next several months.

It seems to be too sharp of a rise in rates and it happened too quickly after The Fed announcement to be attributed to QE2.

But then again, who am I to disagree with such a distinguished and well qualified expert? We should know though in the next few months whether Dr. Jones is right or not. Let’s hope for all our sakes he’s not.

Sources:
Quantitative Easing by Wikipedia;
Does Quantitative Easing Work in Boosting the Real Ecomony? by Edward Harrison, November 4, 2010;
'Quantitative Easing': What Does It Really Mean for Investors?, Jeff Cox, CNBC.com, August 23, 2010;
Quantitative Easing Already Goosing Interest Rates, Ted Jones, Jones on Real Estate blog, November 14, 2010.